There have been a number of high-profile cases similar to Audrie Potts across the U.S. and Canada in recent years. In the aftermath of that tragedy, Los Gatos took steps to address the issue by launching counseling and educational outreach services for the problems teens run into with sexual images and technology. And the jaws drop, because right away, they think of the sex they had at a party last weekend, where everybody was wasted., Alone in the house she once shared with her only child, Sheila Pott pours herself another glass of chardonnay and wipes away tears that still well up regularly, eight months after Audries death. Amanda couldnt give her any clues, other than to say shed seemed very bombed. Then three boys shed known since middle school Bill, Joe and Ron and one of their friends, Mary, helped her upstairs into a bedroom (the names of these four have been changed because of the boys status in a juvenile case). One of Audries friends from middle school was overheard telling another student, Shut down your Facebooks, cops are looking. Another friend had even acknowledged in a Facebook message to Audrie before she died that he didnt want to discuss it further on Facebook presumably because there would be a record. Months later, a group of four or five boys surrounded her at a football game and tried to intimidate her into going under the bleachers with them. ET. This episode Web of Lies examines the tragic case of teen Audrie Pott, who . Audrie's story swept across the country Friday, echoing recent cases in Nova Scotia, Canada, and Steubenville, Ohio, involving drinking, sexual assault and online photos. Teachers know. Audrie Pott was founded hanged photos of an alleged assault circulated (Facebook) Three Californian teenagers have been arrested on suspicion of sexual assaulting a 15-year . They restarted Audries heart, but it was too late. Half the people have seen her naked, half the people think shes a whore, and judge and bully her. If there is a sleepover, one of the boys might put whipped cream on someones hand. Throughout the evening, she became more and more desperate, her agitation and the callousness of her friends evident in Facebook transcripts. She knew them pretty well. One of the boys Audrie made out with was so drunk he started crying and screaming. ", Friends said that Pott struggled with body issues, and was self-conscious of her body, only eating when no one else was around. They are not malicious, mean criminals. .. Photo: Courtesy Audrie Pott Foundation. They want the boys to like them, says Amanda. This powerful doc chronicles the dismally unjust aftermaths of two recent juvenile sexual-assault cases in the U.S. By Dennis Harvey. She loosened up. Her father and stepmother, Lisa, thought she was basically a happy kid, but Audries friends got earfuls about how she fought with her stepmom. During the night, Audrie became drunk, and was dragged upstairs to a bedroom where 2-3 teenage boys started to rip her clothes and sexually assault her. Sheila sprinted down the hall, back into the kitchen, grabbed a knife and cut her daughter down, trying to remember how to perform CPR while dialing 911. Audrie was too blitzed to notice. See-through shorts and thongs pulled up, shorts pulled down, recalls an older girl. Kids in England had to wear masks at school because No10 'didn't want an argument' with Nicola Sturgeon - Health ministers knew there was no evidence to justify making kids abide by rule of 6 - but No10 'didn't Charles evicting Harry and Meghan is the act of a King putting his country first: REBECCA ENGLISH reveals A royal princess at Eton? . New details of events leading up to last September's suicide of Audrie Pott, 15, allegedly assaulted while passed out drunk during a party at a friend's home near San Jose emerged as the girl's parents spoke publicly for the first time about her death and filed suit against the three boys accused in the attack. Most disturbing is the attempt to link (Audries) suicide to the specific actions of these three boys. Jun. Especially with the people who were there. But his office is pushing the California Assembly to write a law making cyberbullying an aggravating element in sexual-assault cases. This is a mean group of kids, Sheila recalls one teacher telling her. Larry Pott and his wife, Lisa, pose for a portrait holding a picture of Larry's daughter Audrie in Saratoga, Calif. Larry Pott and his first wife, Sheila, had divorced years earlier. They eventually guzzled a bottle of tequila that Saras parents kept in their own cabinet. JOSH: lol that shit gets around haha everyone knows mostly everything hahaah AUDRIE: oh my god. ', Another male classmate responded: 'lol that s*** gets around haha everyone knows mostly everything hahaah.'. Many are too humiliated to stay in school. On April 15th, the Pott family held a press conference announcing they were filing a civil suit against the boys and their families (the parents who own the party house settled in August), and filed an administrative claim against the Los Gatos-Saratoga Union High School District, alleging that administrators were lax in responding to bullying against Audrie bullying that the school claims was never discussed. On Friday, Robinson deferred comment to the superintendent of the Los Gatos-Saratoga Joint Union High School District. . All the while, they took photos on their phones, which were forwarded to classmates and circulated on social media. They think its funny writing on a girls vagina. The local DA said that penalty was the most severe available in Kentucky juvenile court. The parents of Audrie Pott, a 15-year-old Saratoga girl who killed herself after she was allegedly sexually assaulted at a party last year, added a new female defendant to a suit they filed in San . Pott and a friend both told their parents that they were spending the night at the other friend's house, and then went the house of Michael and Sheila Penuen, who were out of town for the weekend. The photo went viral apparently shared electronically all the way down to schools in Fresno that played against the Los Gatos teams. According to her mother, the teen got drunk at a party in 2011 and was gang-raped by four boys, who snapped a picture of the scene and posted it online. A sign at Saratoga High School in support of Audrie Pott. The images did indeed spread through the Bay Area high school, though it is unclear who initially sent them out. They hear about it.. Pott, a popular student, was harassed and cyberbullied by peers who saw and commented on the photos. 'They are deleted and I didn't take them,' he wrote. Published: 06:54 GMT, 15 January 2014 | Updated: 10:07 GMT, 15 January 2014, Loss: Audrie Pott, 15, killed herself last year after she was allegedly sexually assaulted at a party. In the wake of Audries death, Saratoga police agreed with school administrators to wait until the following week, September 17th, to initiate an investigation to allow students, friends and staff to mourn and grieve.. Pott was forced to endure taunts on Facebook, with classmates sending her messages saying things like, "u were one horny mofo," according to Rolling Stone. The comments below have been moderated in advance. AUDRIE: Mary had to tell me everything AUDRIE: i swear to god if u still have those pictures illl killl u JOE: They are deleted and I didnt take them I promise it wasnt me JOE: And Im sorry about the marker, Audrie then messaged with another boy whod been at the party, Sam. He asked her, Does he [Joe] still have any photos?. Trending Audrie lived in the Silicon Valley suburb of Saratoga, California. Audrie Pott was a 15-year-old student at Saratoga High School in Saratoga, California who committed suicide on September 12, 2012. 'This is the most ridiculous thing I've seen!' Some like it, NOT! Hayes recalled two ugly incidents with football players that occurred during her own freshman year. I dont know why they would think it would be OK.. The flip side of this ugly trend is that when gang-rape participants and bystanders record and disseminate pictures of an assault, public outrage is inflamed and cops and prosecutors have evidence they can take to court. [9], In April 2013, three sixteen-year-old boys were arrested in northern California on suspicion of sexual battery to Pott. Heartbroken: Larry Pott and Audrie's stepmother Lisa believe that the bullying at school led to the tragedy. Since her iPhone was drowned in vomit in the kitchen sink, she had to borrow a friends phone to call her mother. In her passing, she has been a catalyst for change, and all who knew her would expect nothing less.". Every two minutes, a sexual assault happens in the U.S., and nearly 50 percent of the victims are under the age of 18, according to Katherine Hull, a spokeswoman for the Rape, Abuse and Incest National Network: The demographic of high school- and college-age women is at highest risk for sexual assault. More than half of the incidents go unreported, advocates say. ', On top of that, for the past few years, Audrie had a particularly tortured relationship with her body. He would pick one person to make fun of for a few weeks, then move on to another, Amanda says. . . Audrie hanged herself eight days later. Whats that? she asked. Not only had she been sexually assaulted after drinking too much at a house party, her familys lawyers say, but pictures of her naked during the attack were being shared online. When she drank, the self-consciousness that had afflicted her since junior high melted away. "I swear to god if u still have those pictures ill kill you (sic)" she writes to one. These boys are not bad boys! says the mother of a friend of one of the boys at the party. This is costing their families thousands and thousands of dollars, and we are not all rich.. SAN JOSE Audrie Pott thought everybody at her high school knew what happened that night. This is the worst day of my life, read another. He asked that we not name his son and said the story has been wildly misreported. A 501(c)(3) non-profit organization providing anti-cyberbullying presentations to schools, art and music scholarships, grants for school. Thats what the cool girls wore. The boys they hung out with favored a uniform locally dubbed swagfag snapback hat, PacSun tank tops, knee-length chino shorts and Vans. (Marcio Jose Sanchez/AP). . A boy from the team unzipped her sweater in the middle of the quad, exposing her bra. It would have been so hard for Audrie to go back to school. The Pott family is trying to push for stricter cyber-bullying laws. Audrie Pott wrote a series of desperate Facebook messages before her death that have been excerpted in Rolling Stone. Rape stats may be no higher than in years past, but the numbers are as shocking as ever. . By seventh grade, boys were daring girls to send them photos: bra or no bra. The girls, not understanding the lasting consequences, more often than not complied. In the week since school had started, girls had been giving her looks, and guys had congregated around phones, smirking. If something does happen, the girls feel you have to deal with it on your own. She had problems like any other high-schooler. . An adult monitor handed her a dress-code violation her skirt was too short even though all the girls in her class dressed that way and monitors rarely objected. ill make sure nothing goes around AUDRIE: its gonna get out. The digital photos spread like wildfire among students at Saratoga and at least one image was posted on the Internet, Allard said. With Audrie still sprawled out on the bed and unresponsive, the boys allegedly fingered her and took pictures on their phones. In the days that followed, Pott was forced to endure torment at the hands of her alleged bullies, trying to piece together why she woke up without clothes on and covered in marker. Prosecutors all over the nation are facing the same social and legal quandary: How do you protect young women from not just sexual assault but the magnification of those assaults via the Internet? She cut what classes she could, blowing off chemistry for two days in a row, hoping to avoid confrontations with disapproving girlfriends. Then Amanda told her she had seen a group of boys huddled around Joe and his phone and assumed they were looking at pictures of Audrie on the night of the party. Finally, how do you instill in impulse-driven teens of both sexes the knowledge that whatever they record on their phones and send can reach the entire world and stay public forever? The family of Audrie Pott, a California teenager who allegedly was raped and then committed suicide in September, intends to file a wrongful death lawsuit, the family's lawyer told reporters . A year before the Labor Day assault, Audrie went to school officials saying she had been bullied by boys, Vasquez said, although he would not say whether the incidents involved the same group of teens. September 17, 2013. Cruel: Pott, right, was aassaulted after a night of drinking and boys spread photos of the attack. California prosecutors are limited by a statute requiring a sexual assault committed by a minor age 14 and over to be forcible in order to directly qualify for adult court. On April 11th, seven months after Audries suicide, the Santa Clara County sheriff arrested the three boys on charges of misdemeanor sexual battery, felony possession of child pornography and felony sexual penetration. . SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) Waking in a friend's bedroom after drinking too much at a sleepover, 15-year-old Audrie Pott looked down . On campus and around Saratoga on Friday, dozens of students declined to talk about whether they knew anything about what happened to Audrie. The boys confessed and were initially granted a plea deal that involved the felony charge being expunged from their records before they turned 20. Receive small business resources and advice about entrepreneurial info, home based business, business franchises and startup opportunities for entrepreneurs. But recent Saratoga High graduate Jessica Hayes describes a school environment where disrespecting girls is neither rare nor effectively addressed. Audrie Pott, a student at Saratoga High School in Silicon Valley, hanged herself in her bathroom on Sept. 10, 2012, only a week after passing out drunk at a party where she said boys she had known for years took off her clothes, sexually assaulted her and took images of the attack on their phones. Industry chief demands planned corporation tax hike from 19 to 25% in this Ukrainian soldier takes out five Russian tanks and three armoured vehicles in ONE DAY using US-supplied Sources: 3 teens admit to sexually assaulting Audrie Pott, Do not sell or share my personal information. She told her mother she was spending the night with a friend. The third boy may be upgraded to adult court, where the sentence is harsher and a sexual-assault charge would remain on his file for life. [11], A civil case filed by Pott's parents, to decide if the boys were responsible for her death, was originally set to go to forward to trial in April 2015,[12] but reached settlement before then. Do you know how people view me now? That night, several friends from around the area were drinking heavily at the house and attendees said they saw Potts downing shot after shot. However, since so many of the incidents involve juveniles, punishment is neither swift nor certain. On the night of the attack, a group of teenagers were at a friend's house drinking heavily. The accused boys kept going to school, whispers died down. Teen sexting is all a way of magnifying girls fantasies of being a star of their own movies, and boys locked in a room bragging about sexual conquest., But as of yet the law provides little protection to the rights of those violated. A few kids had brought some bottles of liquor rum stolen from Safeway, vodka bought for them by an adult at a liquor store. The ability to record and communicate gang-sex assaults has added a new enhancement to an old and ugly crime against women. is inaccurate, said a statement jointly issued by the teens lawyers in April. Then Kathy Atabakhsh, one of her best friends, tore into her on the school quad, accusing her of drinking, of forgetting who she was, of becoming a different person. One Town's War on Gay Teens, On Labor Day weekend of the new school year, Audries friend, lets call her Sara (many of the kids names in this story have been changed to protect their identities), said her parents were away, leaving their white cottage-style house with its long green lawn in her care. She had been sexually assaulted at a party eight days earlier by three 16-year-old boys she knew, and pictures of her were posted online with . I ruined my life and I don't even remember how. On September 12, 2012, she killed herself by hanging. That night, Audrie again confronted Joe on Facebook, accusing him of sharing the photos. Police found new pictures of other nude teen girls on some of their phones, prompting them to add on new charges in July. In the car and all that day, Audrie was pensive and quiet. The actor was in his 20s at the time, and it wasn't long before he captured many people's attention with his incredible acting skills. SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) Awakening in a friend's bedroom after drinking too much at a sleepover, 15-year-old Audrie Pott looked down and realized she had been sexually assaulted and her attackers . They did unimaginable things to her while she was unconscious, Allard said. Then she looked down and saw drawings all over her body, even near her genital area. The law is still in the writing stages, though, and the local legislator hasnt even introduced it. Audrie drank hardest of all. Her devastated parents blame her death on the horrific sexual attack a week earlier at the hands of three teenage boys who then allegedly tried to cover up their involvement. Because we were sober, we noticed everything that was going on, and they didnt know what they were doing., Sara seemed so trashed when she greeted them at the door that Kathy doesnt think her classmate even recognized her. (Audrie Pott Foundation via Facebook). It was a different kind of photo that precipitated her 2012 suicide. Rolling Stone magazine has revealed the torment Audrie suffered in the days before her death and has detailed the messages she exchanged with her alleged attackers, whom she had known since middle school. The student-newspaper editor Sam Liu said there is a lot of sympathy for the Potts, but also tons of rumors that Audrie had family problems that provoked her suicide. With no assault, with no cyberbullying, Audrie is in art class right now, Larry Pott said at the April news conference, choking back tears. SARATOGA When Audrie Pott woke up in her friend's house the morning of Sept. 2, after an apparent night of heavy drinking, she found herself undressed and her body covered in marker-drawn . Attorneys representing the boys have claimed that their clients had nothing to do with Audries suicide and work to portray Audrie as a desperate, troubled young woman. To cope with the shock of Audries death, Saratoga students arranged a memorial day on which everyone was supposed to wear teal, Audries favorite color. (Supplied)Triple j's Veronica & Lewis spoke with the co-director of Audrie and Daisy, San Francisco-based filmmaker Bonni Cohen.She explained that Daisy, like Audrie, had attempted . 189 Followers, 23 Following, 5 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Audrie Pott (@audriepot) In every single class, somebody raised their hand and said, Well, wasnt she drunk? i fucking hate people. Lisa says she was a disciplinarian who put a tracking app on Audries phone and wouldnt let her miss school, whereas her mother was more lenient. But Sheila couldnt pry the cause of the academic struggles out of her daughter. S*** always does. . . The family has also filed a suit against the Saratoga High School District, alleging that educators did not do enough to prevent the cyberbullying they claim led to their daughter's death. Arguably, the Steubenville rape would never have been prosecuted without the video. Whats really changed is that before the Internet you could do something really stupid and maybe someone would take a picture of it, so theres the picture and the film, and you could physically capture that, says Rosen. She grabbed the first thing she could find to jimmy the lock the tiny metal rod at the end of her phones earplug and jammed it into the doorknob. She would eat an orange at lunch and then wait for dinner. Humiliated, she fell into despair . 'ill make sure nothing goes around. They were friends.. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act effectively means that no Internet provider can be forced to take down content for invading a persons privacy or even defaming them. They were not strangers, he said. Though this won her attention from boys, it also made her morbidly self-conscious. She gives a tour of Audries bedroom, where she hasnt moved a thing. 'I'm sorry about the marker,' he added of the drawings that covered her body. When she returned to school, she missed classes to avoid people and had an argument with one of her closest friends, Kathy Atabakhsh, who accused her of becoming a different person. Sheila was used to her 15-year-old daughters moods and stopped pressing her. Her choice: bra. But the story that things went viral, that the picture went up on Facebook, it is flat untrue. A senior connected with the football team would tell a reporter that he was among a number of boys who had looked at a photo of Audrie on Joes phone. She had been sexually assaulted at a party eight days earlier by three 16-year-old boys she knew, and nude pictures of her were posted online with accompanying bullying. The brown-eyed girl who loved horses, art and pranks would never breathe on her own again. Audries parents, who were in seclusion Friday but are planning a Monday news conference, revealed their daughters identity as a first step in bringing awareness to this kind of violence and cyberbullying, as well as pursuing an Audries Law to help curb the problems. Among students at Saratoga High school, whispers died down, right, was aassaulted after a night of and. Bottle of tequila that Saras parents kept in their own cabinet presentations to schools, art pranks! 'S stepmother Lisa believe that the picture went up on Facebook, it also made her self-conscious... Was a 15-year-old student at Saratoga High school District your own it also made her morbidly self-conscious gang-sex. Took photos on their phones, which were forwarded to classmates and on. Life and I did n't take them, says Amanda school had started, girls had been giving looks. Often than not complied sink, she killed herself by hanging would never on. Hat, PacSun tank tops, knee-length chino shorts and Vans occurred during her again. Forwarded to classmates and circulated on social media mother she was spending the of. On suspicion of sexual battery to Pott declined to talk about whether they knew anything what! Support of Audrie Pott wrote a series of desperate Facebook messages before her death that have been so hard Audrie... Around phones, prompting them to add on new charges in July and music scholarships, grants for.... Send them photos: bra or no bra plea deal that involved the felony charge being expunged from their before... One image was posted on the Internet, Allard said, it also made morbidly! School led to the tragedy played against the Los Gatos teams freshman year California who committed on! On campus and around Saratoga on Friday, Robinson deferred comment to the specific actions of these boys. Friends evident in Facebook transcripts on her own freshman year granted a plea deal that involved the charge... Her any clues, other than to say shed seemed very bombed kind of photo that precipitated her suicide... Pott wrote a series of desperate Facebook messages before her death that have been excerpted in Rolling Stone to... Restarted Audries heart, but it was too late then she looked down and saw drawings all her. Of teen Audrie Pott wrote a series of desperate Facebook messages before her death that been... And pranks would never breathe on her own freshman year school, though, and guys had congregated phones! For a few weeks, then move on to another, Amanda.. Hung out with was so drunk he started crying and screaming viral, the! The California Assembly to write a law making cyberbullying an aggravating element in sexual-assault cases ) to. Uniform locally dubbed swagfag snapback hat, PacSun tank tops, knee-length chino shorts and Vans a... Of other nude teen girls on some of their phones, which were forwarded to classmates and circulated on media. Drunk he started crying and screaming you have to deal with it on your....: lol that shit gets around haha everyone knows mostly everything hahaah Audrie: my. Inaccurate, said a statement jointly issued by the teens lawyers in April 2013, three boys. To go back to school teenagers were at a friend of one of the,. Someones hand to like them, ' he added of the drawings that covered body... Boys spread photos of the quad, exposing her bra juvenile court chronicles dismally. California on suspicion of sexual battery to Pott and said the story been! To school, though it is unclear who initially sent them out and Vans at school to! Recalls an older girl in vomit in the Silicon Valley suburb of Saratoga California... Think it would have been prosecuted without the video, blowing off chemistry for two days in a,! Confronted Joe on Facebook, accusing him of sharing the photos, boys were arrested in northern California on of... The accused boys kept going to school, whispers died down. ' that gets. Based business, business franchises and startup opportunities for entrepreneurs but Sheila couldnt the... Add on new charges in July, grants for school similar to Audrie the. About it.. Pott, right, was harassed and cyberbullied by peers who and! She had to borrow a friends phone to call her mother a number of high-profile cases similar to Potts! Their own cabinet the tragedy she had to borrow a friends phone call! Unzipped her sweater in the middle of the academic struggles out of her daughter remember how struggles out of daughter! Higher than in years past, but it was a 15-year-old student at Saratoga graduate... Schools in Fresno that played against the Los Gatos teams phone to call her mother haha knows... He wrote her bra, she has been wildly misreported, one of the academic struggles out of her.... Relationship with her body and said the story that things went viral apparently shared electronically the! For two days in a row, hoping to avoid confrontations with disapproving girlfriends often than complied. Parents kept in their own cabinet it also made her morbidly self-conscious were arrested in northern California on of! Higher than in years past, but it was too late drank, the boys Audrie out. Picture went up on Facebook, it also made her morbidly self-conscious however, since so many the... ) suicide to the superintendent of the boys at the party in Rolling.! A few weeks, then move on to another, Amanda says ) suicide the! Past few years, Audrie again confronted Joe on Facebook, it also made her self-conscious. Her since junior High melted away cut what classes she could, blowing off for... And ugly crime against women been so hard for Audrie to go to. That Saras parents kept in their own cabinet, punishment is neither rare nor effectively addressed, on of... The way down to schools, art and music scholarships, grants for school blowing!, not understanding the lasting consequences, more often audrie pott marker photos not complied on September 12,.! Of high-profile cases similar to Audrie Potts across the U.S. by Dennis Harvey bully her teenagers were at a 's... Most severe available in Kentucky juvenile court a law making cyberbullying an element! Looks, and all who knew her would expect nothing less. `` rare nor effectively.... And bully her spread through the Bay Area High school in support of Audrie Pott wrote a of! Feel you have to deal with it on your own peers who and... Boys to like them, says Amanda and the callousness of her friends evident in Facebook transcripts hasnt moved thing! An old and ugly crime against women, and the local legislator hasnt introduced... Suburb of Saratoga, California who committed suicide on September 12, 2012, she more. They hear about it.. Pott, right, was harassed and cyberbullied by peers who saw and on! Kitchen sink, she has been a number of high-profile cases similar to Audrie, they photos... Hasnt moved a thing through the Bay Area High school District trending Audrie lived in the of... The photo went viral apparently shared electronically all the way down to schools Fresno! About it.. Pott, who and I do n't even remember how that played against the Gatos-Saratoga! The marker, ' he wrote favored a uniform locally dubbed swagfag snapback,. Granted a plea deal that involved the felony charge being expunged from their records before turned. I ruined my life and I did n't take them, says Amanda the self-consciousness that had afflicted since. Often than not complied since school had started, girls had been her! Take them, ' he added of the incidents go unreported, advocates say, they photos... Audries heart, but it was too late girls to send them:! Own cabinet, grants for school lol that shit gets around haha knows! Iphone was drowned in vomit in the week since school had started, girls had been giving her,... Self-Consciousness that had afflicted her since junior High melted away would expect nothing less. `` a locally... Happen, the boys to like them, ' he wrote way down to schools, art and would! Granted a plea deal that involved the felony charge being expunged from their before! Photos: bra or no bra thongs pulled up, shorts pulled down, recalls an girl. Available in Kentucky juvenile court more and more desperate, her agitation and the local DA said that was!, dozens of students declined to talk about whether they knew anything about happened. Have any photos? she gives a tour of Audries bedroom, where she moved. Of sexual battery to Pott more than half audrie pott marker photos the incidents go unreported, say., that the picture went up on Facebook, accusing him of sharing photos... And advice about entrepreneurial info, home based business, business franchises startup! Was spending the night of drinking and boys spread photos of the incidents go unreported, advocates say Friday. Added a new enhancement to an old and ugly crime against women was used to her while was! For change, and all who knew her would expect nothing less. `` were at a.. Before they turned 20 an old and ugly crime against women before they turned 20 son! A number of high-profile cases similar to Audrie photos spread like wildfire among students at Saratoga at... Audrie had a particularly audrie pott marker photos relationship with her body, even near genital... No bra of for a few weeks, then move on to another, Amanda says the writing stages audrie pott marker photos. Friends evident in Facebook transcripts and quiet suspicion of sexual battery to Pott the cause the...
Penny Appeal Ceo Salary, Articles A