Use and Selection Guide. The dorsal D-ring (between the worker's shoulder blades) is used with a fall arrest system. THS 42.4x2.6: The modified transom is less than 13% heavier but more than a 13% stronger lowering maximum bending stress to an acceptable level. Refer to manufacturer specifications for activation details. This hybrid system uses one line (firmly anchored at both ends) as the anchorage for another. ropebook 24th July 2019. Body belts may be used in limited instances (e.g., as part of a positioning device system). This calculator will determine the fall factor and impact force on a climber. DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. Fall Restraint Systems and Positioning Devices To learn more. calculating shock load on rope . How-To Calculate Load Weight: example 1steel sheet/block. The shock load calculator automatically assumes the mass impacts at the worst possible position generating highest possible bending moment and hence greatest stress. As a result, when the tide goes out the boat is left on the mud with a list of about 10 degrees. Forum software by XenForo 2010-2020 XenForo Ltd. JavaScript is disabled. Heavy plywood is a common choice for covering temporary holes in floors and roofs (see Figure 9), but plywood strength and durability can vary. Modern ropes are so stable, that under normal conditions and with careful use they cannot break. The force generated at the moment of maximum rope elongation, is known as impact force. TreeBuzz was created to help unite the Arborist community from around the world and provide a platform to share current information and exchange ideas that help increase safety, efficiency and professionalism in real time! In addition to calculating the total fall clearance distance before beginning work on an elevated level, it is important to evaluate the swing fall hazard at the edges where a worker might fall. Calculate the shock response spectrum of the synthesis. Thank you very much for your information, one of the few times I actually got an answer right away no running me in circles or trying to sell me something. Workplace Safety & Health Topics Page: Prevention Through Design. Equipment used for hoisting is not suitable for use in a fall protection system (see 29 CFR 1926.502(d)(18)). Therefore slack should be avoided. At the protection points, that is where the rope goes through the carabiners etc, there is friction between the rope and metal. In the case of the trunk-tie the anchor and TIP are different - the anchor is 1x the shock load, the TIP is double the shock load. Synthetic lines have been assigned comparison factors against which they are compared to manila line. Is there a simple way to do it, if so, I sure would like to know. David Geffens Yacht: Everything You Want To Know. Each type of line, natural fiber, synthetic and wire rope, have different breaking strengths and safe working loads. Calculating shock load for an elastic wire requires knowing several factors: Modulus of elasticity (E) = 11,500,00 pounds per square inch (new rope) or 15,000,000 pounds per square inch (stretched rope), Area factor of rope (area factor)each particular kind of rope has an associated area factor, Metallic area of the rope (A) = diameter of the rope in inches x diameter of the rope in inches x area factor. The Center of Balance or center of gravity is important to keep in mind. I have made mention of a gin rope, or a gin. It seems to me that Safe Working Load should also be provided by the manufacturer, since there are so many variables involved, as you indicated above. But more on that later. You may verify the results obtained in this calculator by checking
", Yes, I agree to receive newsletters from Bergfreunde GmbH by email comprising the Bergfreunde Newsletter (product information, promotions) and Bergfreunde Deals (special offers) for outdoor products as well as occasional surveys about my interests and information relating to Bergfreunde GmbH. You will find further reading on this subject in reference publications(4 & 32), Fig 4. This section provides information on evaluating: Total Fall Clearance Distance for PFAS 4 (c)-(d), respectively. ISEA. Plug in the values in the following example: load = 200 pounds, falling distance = 12 inches, area factor = 0.472, diameter of rope = 0.25 inches, metallic area = 0.0295 inches^2, modulus of elasticity = 15,000,000 pounds per square inch, and length of cord = 10 feet (120 inches). The panel overlaps the supporting surfaces around the hole far enough for needed support. Some knots arent particularly damaging, while others can be devastating. At the end of three seconds you'd be falling at 30 m/sec. mandalorian baby shower games; loungefly wall-e crossbody . Wire Rope Calculator. Indoor & Outdoor SMD Screens, LED Displays, Digital Signage & Video Wall Solutions in Pakistan I guess to answer the first question of the thread, I just make experienced guesses. OSHA, 2002, A Guide to Scaffold Use in the Construction Industry. jigsaw pshe vocabulary; foreclosed homes in brandywine, md; keeshond puppies for sale in maryland; yale law school courses spring 2022; Any employee performing roofing work between the warning line and the roof edge must be protected using another form of fall protection. An uneven load or one that involves shock is called a(n) _____. With this automated feature, the operator can focus on controlling the load, monitoring his or her environment and ensuring that the load remains secure. CalQlata prefers to define a shock load as that which is subject to an acceleration greater than that due to gravity. This value can then be compared to the vertical clearance actually available at the work location. Originally published by American Society of Safety Engineers. However, this is simply one of many definitions and therefore provided for information only. X=63.25 - the left hypotenuse, or rope distance to the load from control side anchor. D-ring shift: 1 foot. So just how technical do you get while calculating shock load? It may not display this or other websites correctly. This makes sense, when you think about the numbers. This value can then be compared to the available vertical clearance actually available at the work location. Effective lanyards are maintained in a clean, intact condition, and inspected prior to each use for wear, tear, and any obvious distortion or signs that the fall arrest (energy-absorbing) system has been activated (see 29 CFR 1926.502(d)(21)). The equation for calculating shock loads. Safety Monitoring Systems For anchoring between interior building framing or a window opening. Emergency response planning will identify necessary emergency response training and critical resources (e.g., trained on-site fall arrest rescue team and rescue equipment). Heres all you need to know about rope strength. A sliding fitting (rope grab or shuttle) connects to the line and a lanyard connects the workers harness to that sliding fitting. Workers are not allowed in the area between the warning line and the unprotected edge, except during roofing work (see 29 CFR 1926.502(f)(3)). Damage is more likely to occur if the components are dropped when disassembled, transported in vehicles, or stored in areas not protected from conditions that could cause corrosion or distortion. Calculate the weight of a steel plate (shown in figure 1) 2ft wide X 5ftlong X 1inch (0.0833ft) thick. Where guardrails cannot be used, fall restraint is a better option than fall arrest for a work area with limited clearance below. Observe the following precautions with slings. Rope lifeline attaches to an anchorage at the top and hangs vertically down through the work area. In this case the free fall distance is 3 feet (less than OSHA's 6-foot maximum); however, the total fall distance is 14.5 feet (more than the typical space between levels in a building under construction). Shock load is the term used to describe the sudden force exerted when an object suddenly accelerates or decelerates, such as when a falling object hits the ground, a fastball strikes a catcher's glove or a diver begins to leap off a diving board. In reality any dynamically applied load can be regarded as a shock with varying degrees of intensity. Both terms refer to rope strength but theyre not the same measurement. Don't miss out on the latest offers & products - plus 5 off your next order! Dog Agility Training At It's Finest. At the base of the tree, we tied an Impact Block (which has a built-in load cell) and then tied the other end of the test rope to the Impact Block (Figure 2) so it could measure tension in the fall of the rope. F = m a (m=mass, a = accelleration). Depending on their geometry and sag angle, horizontal lifelines may be subjected to greater loads than the impact load imposed by an attached component. The test rope ran through a block attached to the tree. To distribute the loads let us consider the result of the Loads that we previously calculated: Total Dead Loads (e.g., self-weight and SDL)= (6.25+6) kN/m2 = 12.25 kN/m2. What is her total fall clearance distance? Plan. zero deflection) and the only deflection considered in the calculation comes from the impacted system. 16 fpm chain hoist: 1.25x Load 32 fpm chain hoist: 1.5x Load 64 fpm chain hoist: 2.0x Load. In dealing with this situation I have snapped several polypropylene ropes of breaking strain 28 tonnes. WISHA. It awaits, lurking, for you to . Temporary or permanent anchor point on a vertical concrete wall. Controlling Exposure to Hazardous Drugs, see OSHA's Safety and Health Topics Page for updated information. I know the importance of being geared up for anything. Write down the equation to determine shock load in pounds: shock load = load x [1 + (1 + (2 x FD x A x E)/(load x L))^1/2]. A controlled access zone is a clearly marked, designated work area where certain work (e.g., overhand bricklaying) may take place without conventional fall protection systems (see 29 CFR 1926.500(b)). However, a manufacturer may also test a ropes minimum tensile strength. Ladder safety devices are available as a cable (i.e., vertical lifeline) or fixed rail system (see Figure 16 and 29 CFR 1926.1053(a)(18), (a)(22), (a)(23)). Knowing the Mass [weight] and Distance of travel you can calculate the Impact Velocity [ the force applied when you come to a sudden stop] = square root of 2 times the distance times force of gravity [9.8 meters per second squared]. In our comparison this means that the payout rope length must be replaced by an effective payout rope length, which is always smaller than the actual rope length. Although some components may look the same, they may not be interchangeable if they are from different manufacturers or from different equipment series made by the same manufacturer. The fall is therefore just as "hard" However this only applies the force, that impacts on the rope. Full-Body Harnesses To convert use the following formula. The accuracy of all calculations performed in the shock load calculator is as precise as the input data you enter. I don't know what Kenny might say, but I don't calculate nothing. Copyright 2018-2020 TreeBuzz.com This has the result that some of the energy generated in the fall, is released onto the belayer and the person falling "loses energy". Personal Fall Protection Equipment for Personal Fall Arrest Systems Self-Rescue Figure 2. (.5 X 3.14 = 1.57) Then using the formula above: 1.57 2 X 900 = 2,218 pounds of breaking strength. This prevents the rope from stretching in case of a fall. To see what happens if we immerse the above plate (:1.0m x th:0.02m) 10m below the surface of the sea where it is impacted by a 20 metre x 14 second ocean wave and a coincident 3m/s current: Using CalQlata's Waves, Added Drag and Fluid Forces calculators we can identify a total horizontal force of 29,170.989508N for this wave on the plate, i.e. A safety monitoring system uses a competent person as a safety monitor who can recognize and warn workers of fall hazards (see 29 CFR 1926.500(b); 29 CFR 1926.502(h)(1)). Used in personal fall protection systems. Wire rope is sometimes used for the top rails and midrails. Excessive rope rotation can damage a wire rope. A stairrail system is a vertical barrier that runs along the unprotected side edge of a stairway to prevent workers from falling to lower levels (see Figures 5 and 6). Our goal is to make science relevant and fun for everyone. A shorter rope at the same fall height is more uncomfortable than a longer one. This is why it is so important to use some type of energy absorbing device between you . OSHA. A guardrail system can be used as a barrier installed to prevent workers from falling off a work surface edge to a lower level. rope length = 2 m, fall length = 4 m so fall factor = 4/2 = 2. Another effective attenuation technique is to mount the component via elastomeric bushings or wire rope isolators. Guardrails can also be used to keep workers from falling into holes or openings in decking or floors (see 29 CFR 1926.501(b)(4)(i); 29 CFR 1926.502(b); Figure 2). Train. Off-site emergency response personnel may rescue suspended workers, although most 911 responders are not trained in how to do so. So now you have shock load = 200 x [1 + (1 + 442.5)^1/2]. So for example when you are top roping and attached to the rope or pulling equipment behind you. E = mv. If the rug gets snagged by the rope, the inspector has to stop and assess the wire rope's condition. I have a 36ft trawler with lots of windage and would like to get a reliable answer before its time to buy new lines. Often, components are supplied together as a set. Some manufacturers offer adjustable length lanyards. if K = 100 then the acceleration of the mass at the time of impact is 100 times greater than gravitational acceleration. The maximum force which arises in a fall is: Here m signifies the mass of the climber, g gravity, E the elasticity modulus (a value dependent on the material), A the rope diameter and f is the so-called fall factor. This puts a very great strain on the mooring lines as the boat attempts to slide away. A deceleration device is a mechanism (e.g., tearing or deforming lanyards) that serves to dissipate energy during a fall to limit the energy and stress imposed on a worker during a fall. Figure 17. In those cases the shock force is. The more elastic the rope, the softer the fall. Self-retracting lanyards that do not limit free fall to two feet or less need to sustain, at a minimum, 5,000 pounds applied to the device with the lanyard in the fully extended position (see 29 CFR 1926.502(d)(13)). Self-retracting lanyards typically activate, and thus limit free fall distance, within 2 feet. These typically had bowline knots tied at the boat end and several round turns with two half hitches on the shore mooring post. The concept of severity as a function of fall factor is useful only with a dynamic rope. Fortunately, the tensile strength which a climbing rope must have is standardised. For use around structural steel or I-beams. As an example, if you had a piece of " manila line and wanted to find the breaking strength, you would first calculate the circumference. If so what is it? . The above transom survives this load case as the resultant bending stress (140MPa) is well below the expected minimum specified yield for structural steel. To determine the force needed to restrain a worker, consideration is given to the force that would be generated by the worker walking, leaning, or sliding down the working surface. Premade guardrails are particularly susceptible to damage if not handled properly when disassembled and stored. Chris Cowell is one of the group. This isnt ideal, as you can imagine. Worker Deaths by Falls (NIOSH document 2000-116). United States Institute of Theater Technology: Understanding Shock Loads, Bridon International: Steel Rope Technical Information. The cable (flexible carrier) or rail (rigid carrier) is attached by mountings at the top and bottom of the fixed ladder, with intermediate mountings or cable guides for added strength. See the bottom of the page for a proposed conversion procedure. Positive rigging is static rigging where the pulley is above the rigging point and the system is pre-loaded (usually by the ground crew) to reduce dynamic force on the system components. When combined together, all of these issues can have a substantial effect on a ropes ability to carry loads. Weight = 408.3 lbs. Updated on July 12, 2022. No date. For example: driving a nail into a piece of wood. (.5 X 3.14 = 1.57) Then using the formula above: 1.57 2 X 900 = 2,218 pounds of breaking strength. Unit weight of steel is 490 lbs/ft. Deceleration occurs over a maximum distance of 3.5 feet (see 29 CFR 1926.502(d)(16)(iv)). (See 29 CFR 1926 Subpart M, Appendix C(II)(h), Tie-off considerations). NIOSH. A sudden extension in the line activates a locking mechanism that typically includes a deceleration device. Staking is . Example 1a Used before a structure is fully framed. Fallen Worker Rescue This value can then be compared to the vertical clearance actually available at the work location. 2004. Fall hazards can be addressed in two main ways: Recognizing fall hazards and planning to control them before work begins is critical for determining the best methods and equipment for protecting workers during construction activities at heights. Inspecting a lanyard involves beginning at one end and continuing to the opposite end. After an exhaustive search on line, including this forum, I am unable to find any formulas for calculating shock cord sizes, lengths, etc. Divide the numerator by the denominator, as per the order of operations. K1 = bottom spring rate. It is also important to make sure that the increased fall height of the climber does not lead to a higher risk of accidents, for example collision with the rock face, the ground or even the belayer, if the fall height is longer than the payout rope! Anchorage For specific cases, SLTC, in conjunction with the U.S. Forest Service Products Laboratory, can evaluate plywood strength degradation. We'll answer in the meantime! Factor 'K' essentially defines the number of times 'a' (acceleration) in the formula (F = M.a) is greater than 'g' (gravitational acceleration)
Ladder safety devices or systems are used to climb fixed ladders. Just being able to calculate breaking strength doesnt give one a safety margin. For activities near the framed wall top plate. Typical protective layers may include liquid latex compounds, penetrating oils, sheet plastics, and interlocking membranes. For ease of explanation, a vector force is typically trying to pull horizontally as well as vertically. First, calculate the area of the wire rope using the area factor for 7 x 19 GAC in the table. You are using an out of date browser. Its either a 1/2", 5/8", or 3/4 bullrope. but it is essentially a collection of small filaments wound around each other in a manner that largely retains its shape when bent, crushed and/or tensioned.. Add 442.5 to 1 within the parentheses to get shock load = 200 x [1 + (443.5)^1/2]. Knots and splices will reduce the breaking strength of a line by as much as 50 to 60 percent. PFAS components include an anchorage, connectors, and a full-body harness, and may include a shock-absorbing lanyard, a retractable lifeline, and/or a deceleration device (see 29 CFR 1926.500(b)). Communication Towers webpage. The worker designated as the safety monitor may not perform other job tasks that could take attention away from the monitoring function (see 29 CFR 1926.502(h)(1)(v)). Even higher loads were generated at lower scope ratios. Converting wave force (F) into mass (m) for input into the Shock calculator you may use the formula; The properties of the wave generating the above force was calculated using Linear theory in 150 metres of water depth (using CalQlata's. Date: 07/31/2019 Previous Blog - Glossary Shock loading can occur in any situation where the load on the crane suddenly increases. 4 (a)-(b) and Figs. Workers need to be fitted with the correct harness size. Unexpected end of JSON input. Effective handrails are 30 to 37 inches high and meet the guardrail strength requirements (i.e., able to withstand 200 pounds of weight applied within two inches of the top edge in any downward or outward direction at any point along the top edge) (see 29 CFR 1926.1052(c)(5), (c)(6)). A ladder climbing system should not be confused with a "climb assist" system, which consists of motorized equipment that ascends the ladder and partially bears the workers weight. Effective temporary handrails have a minimum clearance of 3 inches between the handrail and walls, stairrail systems, and other objects (see 29 CFR 1926.1052(c)(11)). K2 = Top spring rate. Jan 30, 2013. From your wording about starting with the tensile strength RATING suggest Working Load includes possible reductions from Tensile Strength caused by knots. This safety factor would be used for example for the sizing of a wire rope used in a cable-stayed bridge. Lanyards are available in a variety of lengths. SHIB 03-24-2004, updated 2011. Your email address will not be published. Dynamic rope elongation describes how much the rope can stretch in the case of fall, which means how elastic the rope is. Its time to buy new lines sometimes used for example: driving a nail into a piece of wood suddenly... That under normal conditions and with careful use they can not break distance... Used as a set and stored Guide to Scaffold use in the shock load = X... Glossary shock loading can occur in any situation where the load from control side anchor a window opening component... Natural fiber, synthetic and wire rope used in a cable-stayed bridge test a ropes ability to loads! Device system ) or other websites correctly vertical concrete wall, 2002, a Guide to use... A ) - ( b ) and the only deflection considered in shock! So stable, that is where the load on the rope is sometimes used for the sizing a. Also test a ropes ability to carry loads the opposite end mount the component elastomeric! The mud with a list of about 10 degrees to keep in.! A manufacturer may also test a ropes ability to carry loads premade guardrails are particularly susceptible to damage if handled... Trying to pull horizontally as well as vertically 1926.502 ( d ), respectively ( shown in 1. Distance, within 2 feet new lines information only, while others can be regarded as set. Turns with two half hitches on the rope, or rope distance to opposite... Hitches on the crane suddenly increases layers may include liquid latex compounds, penetrating oils, plastics... Attaches to an anchorage at the top rails and midrails: 1.57 2 900!.5 X 3.14 = 1.57 ) then using the formula above: 1.57 2 X 900 = 2,218 pounds breaking. The available vertical clearance actually available at the top rails and midrails instances e.g.! Factor and impact force on a vertical concrete wall and a lanyard connects the workers to. Generating highest possible bending moment and hence greatest stress regarded as a set an greater. List of about 10 degrees a substantial effect on a ropes minimum tensile strength caused by.. A window opening 1 + ( 1 + 442.5 ) ^1/2 ] Equipment for personal arrest... To manila line fall Restraint is a better option than fall arrest for work... Manila line friction between the rope goes through the carabiners etc, there is friction between the is... Get while calculating shock load calculator is as precise as the anchorage for cases! Can be regarded as a result, when the tide goes out the boat end and several round turns two... 4 & 32 ), respectively known as impact force on a climber Technology Understanding! See the bottom of the wire rope is sometimes used for the top rails midrails... And the only deflection considered in the calculation comes from the impacted system tensile... ( b ) and the only deflection considered in the table performed in the shock?. Is where the rope is sometimes used for the top and hangs vertically down the! Type of energy absorbing device between you the importance of being geared for. Out the boat attempts to slide away and continuing to the vertical clearance actually available at the same fall is... Buy new lines splices will reduce the breaking strength of a positioning device ). Calqlata prefers to define a shock load as that which is subject to anchorage. Of these issues can have a substantial effect on a climber = 2,218 pounds of breaking strain tonnes. Fortunately, the softer the fall (.5 X 3.14 = 1.57 ) then the! Further reading on this subject in reference publications ( 4 & 32 ), respectively rope.! Can then be compared to the rope or pulling Equipment behind you calculate breaking.. Geared up for anything would be used as a result, when the tide goes out the boat left. Data you enter have is standardised side anchor fitting ( rope grab or shuttle ) connects to the from. These issues can have a substantial effect on a climber hybrid system uses one line ( firmly at... Hitches on the crane suddenly increases a piece of wood Systems Self-Rescue 2. Safety margin deceleration occurs over a maximum distance of 3.5 feet ( see 29 CFR 1926.502 ( )! The worst possible position generating highest possible bending moment and hence greatest stress gravitational! 1926 Subpart m, Appendix c ( II ) ( h ), Tie-off considerations ) workers from off! These typically had bowline knots tied at the moment of maximum rope elongation describes how the... Wire rope isolators combined together, all of these issues can have a substantial effect a... Xenforo 2010-2020 XenForo Ltd. JavaScript is disabled within 2 feet and Health Topics Page Prevention... Top roping and attached to the tree a reliable answer before its time to buy new.! Loads were generated at lower scope ratios anchorage for another maximum distance of 3.5 feet ( see 29 1926... Sltc, in conjunction with the tensile calculating shock load on rope RATING suggest working load includes possible reductions from tensile RATING... Center of Balance or Center of Balance or Center of gravity is important to keep in mind working load possible... Wide X 5ftlong X 1inch ( 0.0833ft ) thick updated information technical information to... All calculations performed in the case of fall, which means how elastic the rope, have breaking. Proposed conversion procedure boat attempts to slide away energy absorbing device between you interlocking.! Used before a structure is fully framed and would like to know Want. The component via elastomeric bushings or wire rope is self-retracting lanyards typically activate, and thus limit fall... X 19 GAC in the table panel overlaps the supporting surfaces around the hole far enough for support! Subject to an anchorage at the moment of maximum rope elongation, is as... And wire rope, the softer the fall is therefore just as `` hard '' however only! Xenforo 2010-2020 XenForo Ltd. JavaScript is disabled while others can be used, fall =. Supplied together as a barrier installed to prevent workers from falling off a work area with limited clearance below 64. Where the rope or pulling Equipment behind you synthetic and wire rope using the formula above 1.57. A manufacturer may also test a ropes ability to carry loads regarded as a with! Generating highest possible calculating shock load on rope moment and hence greatest stress the accuracy of all calculations performed the! Ropes are so stable, that is where the load from control side anchor - b. That under normal conditions and with careful use they can not be used as a shock with varying of. Rope goes through the work location a sudden extension in the Construction...., calculate the area of the wire rope using the formula above: 1.57 2 X 900 = 2,218 of. Evaluate plywood strength degradation response personnel may rescue suspended workers, although most 911 responders are not trained in to. Used for example when you think about the numbers a sliding fitting ; d calculating shock load on rope falling 30..., 5/8 '', 5/8 '', or a window opening a better option than arrest! Geffens Yacht: Everything you Want to know knots tied at the time of impact is 100 times than... Calculate nothing compounds, penetrating oils, sheet plastics, and thus limit free fall distance within. To a lower level you will find further reading on this subject in publications! Is left on the mooring lines as the anchorage for specific cases, SLTC, in with... Strength but theyre not the same measurement on this subject in reference publications 4! Both ends ) as the anchorage for another see the bottom of wire! Calculator automatically assumes the mass impacts at the moment of maximum rope elongation describes how much rope. Technical do you get while calculating shock load calculator is as precise as the anchorage for.! It is so important to keep in mind of three seconds you & # x27 ; be! = 4 m so fall factor = 4/2 = 2 m, c. ( 16 ) ( 16 ) ( h ), respectively 10 degrees example for the sizing a... Points, that under normal conditions and with careful use they can not break as... Manufacturer may also test a ropes minimum tensile strength caused by knots others can be as. Shuttle ) connects to the load on the crane suddenly increases 442.5 ) ^1/2 ] about starting the! Although most 911 responders are not trained in how to do it, if so, i would. I sure would like to get a reliable answer before its time to new. See the bottom of the wire rope is sometimes used for example when you think the... So now you have shock load calculator is as precise as the for! Theyre not the same measurement for a proposed conversion procedure in a cable-stayed bridge about degrees... Calculator will determine the fall polypropylene ropes of breaking strength per the order of operations Geffens Yacht Everything! Responders are not trained in how to do so more uncomfortable than a longer one this puts a great... 60 percent may include liquid latex compounds, penetrating oils, sheet,..., there is friction between the worker 's shoulder blades ) is used a! It is so important to use some type of energy absorbing device between you Forest Service Laboratory. Drugs, see osha 's safety and Health Topics Page: Prevention through Design therefore just as hard... Like to know about rope strength but theyre not the same fall is! Worst possible position generating highest possible bending moment and hence greatest stress reliable answer before its time to new!